20 years in jail as 200 witness statements are withheld – John Kamara (2010)

“A man who was jailed 19 years ago for the murder of a betting shop manager in Liverpool was freed yesterday by the court of appeal when his conviction was quashed with immediate effect. John Kamara, now 44, from Toxteth, Liverpool, was convicted in 1981 with Raymond Gilbert of the murder of John Suffield, who was stabbed during a bungled robbery.

During the trial Gilbert changed his plea to guilty. Even though Mr Kamara continued to profess his innocence he was found guilty. But evidence emerged that another man confessed to police in 1987. Doubts were also cast on the fairness of Mr Kamara’s identity parade, and a bundle of 201 statements were not disclosed to the defence during the trial.

Mr Kamara’s younger brother Philip said after the ruling: “Justice has come right, but why did it take 20 years when he could have been out 12 years ago?””

“Convicted as a 24-year-old, his prison file shows he wrote more than 300,000 letters to MPs, campaigners and even the pope, fighting for his freedom with only the characters from Radio 4 dramas and the Archers on the radio in his cell for company.

It was the discovery of over 200 previously withheld witness statements that set Kamara’s release on course.

Scheduled to last a week, the judges took only three days to quash the conviction. Handed £46 and a travel pass that ran out at 8pm, he rejoined the world with only the clothes on his back and denied the support automatically given to people rejoining society.

In those first months, he faced the prospect of life on the streets. With no national insurance number, he could not access benefits and so had neither a home nor money.”

In November 2016, John Kamara spoke to students at the University of Leicester and there is an excellent blog post about it here:

Channel 4’s Trial and Error programme took a close look at this case and you can find it on Inside Justice’s TV archive:

About INNOCENT (138 Articles)
Challenging miscarriages of justice since 1993.

1 Comment on 20 years in jail as 200 witness statements are withheld – John Kamara (2010)

  1. Hi,
    Nice article. I like that you mentioned all main parts involved with miscarriages of justice, including poor time management, prosecution’s failures, denial of support upon release, lack of support in following months after release and struggles to cope with the world outside of prison.
    There is only one downside with the article – it states that Mr Kamara was released ‘yesterday’. That would mean 2017, although he was actually released in 2000. Could you please change this, so that people who are new to miscarriages of justice do not get confused?
    Thank you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: